So now that David Haller is in the hands of Melanie Bird, it’s time for David to learn more about his powers, look back at his past, and take a deep dive into his own mind. And this doesn’t involve a trip to Xavier’s School for Gifted Youngsters.
The episode begins with David and the others still on the run from wolves, black masks, and Mackenzie Gray’s character, who we can now call The Eye. As the journey continues, we overhear Melanie Bird say that the human race is evolving. She and her group believes that David is a powerful telepath- potentially telekinetic- meaning he can control matter with his mind.
As David rests in the facility known as Summerland, Dr. Bird tells David that The Divisions were created by the government to track and study people like him and Syd. Ones who cannot be controlled are killed. She asks if David is hearing voices and then tells him to focus on them, despite the pain this power is causing him.
Dr. Bird tells David to concentrate on finding a single voice calling out his name. It’s like turning down a big volume knob. As David focuses, Dr. Bird explains that this is called telepathy. For now, David can rest. Tomorrow, memory work begins. Syd joins David, who is curious about what Melanie meant by memory work.
Let’s find out together. The next day, Melanie poses a question: what if everything people said about David’s supposed illness was a lie? Instead, the voices and hallucinations could just be his powers. And Melanie can help him rewrite the story of his life. Right now, David wonders if there’s even time for that with Division Three still in pursuit.
There’s time, though. Dr. Bird tells David that he is important to her, so she needs him clear and focused. They, along with Ptonomy, sit at a table with rods sticking outward. This, Dr. Bird says, is how her group looks back, finds a person’s abilities, and what triggers them. More than that, you’re made whole. They grab the rods and memory work begins.
The three travel to the past and watch a young David and Amy running through a field. This is memory work, thanks to Ptonomy’s gift as a memory artist. Right now, Ptonomy just wants David to take all of this in, as talking to his younger self and sister could change the memory. It’s best he not do that.
Right now, the idea is for David to accept that this is real, and then the group can focus on taking David back to moments when his ‘illness’ started developing. Melanie will show that this was really just David’s gift and he will soon be whole again.
In essence, this is David’s museum and he can do whatever he wants. He glimpses moments from his youth, like his mother doing garden work with him and marking his height on the wall in their home.
As for David’s father, he was an astronomer, but he passed away. We then watch as David’s father, who we can’t see, reads his son a bedtime story. As David watches his younger self, he soon backs away and the room begins to shake. All of a sudden, voices begin flooding in again.
He breaks free from the memory work, afraid of the memories, but Syd implores him to calm down. She felt the same way on her first time, too. A frantic David, now wanting to leave, is soon put to sleep by Ptonomy.
We then flash back to David speaking with Dr. Poole, played by Scott Lawrence, who asks David about his home life and girlfriend, who apparently left him. While David asks for gum, Dr. Poole notes that the end of a relationship could be disruptive for someone with David’s condition. David’s sleeping just fine, and he states that vapor has helped. Poole asks what David meant by ‘the vapor.’
More than that, he notes that the dynamic of fighting and then making up isn’t good for David, who still has flashes of when he destroyed the kitchen. He needs a more settled environment. David promises to work on that.
We follow David as he leaves his appointment and meets up with Lenny, who asks if he’s good in the head. Turns out that Lenny got her hands on a kitchen range from a girl she finger-banged. Kinky. She and David start walking through an alley.
David soon awakens and receives a glass of milk from Ptonomy. The first time in memory work is always the worst. Syd threw up her first time. She’s doing talk work with Dr. Bird, who thinks that David is the key to winning the war and other things. David admits that he’s impressed with Ptonomy’s memory artist abilities.
Ptonomy explains that his father had a shit memory due to artillery shell in the war causing him to go deaf in one ear. As a result, he was never good with facts. He’d just snap his fingers whenever he forgot Ptonomy’s name. Odd, since Ptonomy remembers everything.
And he does mean everything, like his birth and even being in the womb. Imagine being inside your mother’s body, warm and blind, and then light after some intense pressure. Ptonomy then asks David about that book his father read him- The World’s Angriest Boy in the World– because if David’s parents read that book to him before bed, that’s messed up. David doesn’t remember, but Ptonomy is certain that David’s memories seem clear.
David would rather not talk about it, but hey, it’s not Ptonomy’s deal, either. He’s just the memory guy. Okay, fair enough. Meanwhile, The Eye leads a squadron of soldiers as they continue their pursuit…
Later, at a swing set, David tells Syd that he doesn’t see how the memory work is helping. Syd thought the same when she first arrived. Once she got there, all she wanted was to rescue David. It wouldn’t have mattered what she saw when she was in David’s body.
She still doesn’t understand it. After a flash, she remembers switching places with David and everything in the dayroom growing louder. Between that and the lights, Syd never felt that way before. And then, in addition to glimpsing the blob with yellow eyes, Syd realizes that she’s responsible for killing Lenny. David knows that it’s not Syd’s fault. As Lenny said, you don’t give a newbie a bazooka and act surprised when they blow shit up.
However, Melanie and the others, as well as Division Three, heard Syd using David’s powers. Melanie’s group thought they had found David, but it was actually Syd. Sure enough, Syd soon returned to her own body when en route with Melanie’s team.
David confesses that he’d love to hug Syd or at least hold hands, but that’s uncomfortable for Syd. The closer she gets to someone, there’s this feeling that she equates to being covered with ants or feeling little anxious needles under her skin. It’s all she can do not to scream. That sucks, but as David points out, they’re at least having a romance of the mind. Sweet.
We then cut to David receiving an MRI scan of his brain. The doctor overseeing the process is Cary Loudermilk, played by Bill Irwin. He instructs David not to move or sneeze because it could jumble the scan. As Dr. Loudermilk rattles off a few words, David admits that he talks to himself, too. That or the voices. Cary wasn’t talking to himself, though. He was talking to Kerry. The other Kerry, mind you.
After noting that David has a large amygdala, Cary tells David to think of someone or something that he loves. He begins the scan.
We then cut back to Amy telling David that she thinks that a man- Bill, I’m guessing?- is going to propose to her. David is happy, but Amy doesn’t know for sure. She knows that David and girlfriend, Philly, gets him. David doesn’t think so, but Amy asks why her brother why he can’t have what everyone else has: a nice home and a family. David’s reason? Because he’s sick.
Still in the past, while David is transfixed on a dog, Lenny tries to give her stolen kitchen range to The Greek, played by Eddie Jemison in exchange for drugs. As they speak, their voices become more distorted. The Greek has no need for a stove, even if it could be used to cook, heat a room or, hell, even kill himself.
Soon enough, Lenny does manage to score some drugs that she inserts into a blue bong. David wonders why the drug is blue, but they’re always blue. Lenny asks David how Dr. Poole’s place is since they could probably slip in one day when he’s not home. There’s great score potential, after all. The two soon start inhaling fumes from the bong and they begin to go on a trip.
Oh, but this is all part of memory work. When time freezes, Dr. Bird asks David what he saw when he looked at Lenny, but David doesn’t see the point in that because he was high. Melanie insists that David brushing his abilities off on schizophrenic delusions is part of an old narrative. The things he sees are real. Speaking of, let’s go through time again.
Ptonomy takes us back to David’s session with Dr. Poole. At one particular point, he notes a glitch- a time jump. It’s important that David remember everything. Even if he was focused on something else, the surrounding memory should be intact. If David is still confused, Melanie and Ptonomy will help him find the truth.
The session resumes and Ptonomy spots a flash of David’s kitchen incident six years ago when he used his powers. He tells David to concentrate on where he went. So long as David makes his mind blank, Ptonomy can take them to that particular moment.
So we return to David as a child. David insists that he’s not doing this as the bedroom door suddenly shuts. The room rumbles and shakes as the copy of The World’s Angriest Boy in the World falls to the floor.
Back in the present, Syd checks in on David, as Dr. Bird won’t tell her about David’s memory. David asks Syd if they’re really safe at Summerland. Right now, yes, but she knows that people are searching to experiment on them. Syd promises that she’ll protect David. Well, she thinks it, as David realizes, but Syd doesn’t think so.
After a brief cut to the MRI scan as Dr. Loudermilk tries to figure out where David’s memories are stored, we return to David’s session with Dr. Poole, who asks when David started seeing another world out of the corner of his eye. It began when David was 10 or 11, but the pills Dr. Poole prescribed should help with that. Poole asks if David is supplementing- since he used the word ‘vapor’- but David denies it.
Then Poole asks what David remembers from the years when the visions started. David rattles off a series of constellations and ends up talking about his father studying the stars. Some nights, David’s father would wake him up in the middle of the night and the two would drive out in the truck to look up at the sky. Dad said the stars talk to everyone, including him, but David thought he meant it in a metaphorical sense.
As for what the stars said, David says he’s not supposed to talk about that. Besides, he’s soon drawn to the closet door opening by itself. Dr. Poole, assuring David that he’s in a safe place, closes the door and says that it’s just a closet. Nothing can hurt him.
Back to the MRI scan, David apparently hears a woman’s voice, but it wasn’t Kerry. It was Amy’s.
We see Amy visit the facility, where she learns that there are apparently no records of David Haller or Dr. Kissinger at this hospital. Amy asks the clerk if she’s being coerced, but the woman instead proposes that Amy herself be admitted for observation. She then asks if Amy ever saw a psychiatrist for paranoid delusions.
As Amy prepares to leave, she hears David’s voice. David, in astral form, calls out to her, but he can’t reach her. At the same time, The Eye enters the hospital.
Back to the scan, Cary notes a spike in neural activity. He leaves, but the scan continues anyway. And then David spots the Devil with Yellow Eyes standing before him.
Soon enough, David finds himself out of the chamber. Why? Because the chamber itself, as Dr. Bird and the others soon see, is right outside Summerland.
David tells Dr. Bird that Amy is being held by Division Three, but Bird tells David that he can’t help her. He soon packs up and tells Syd that he’s leaving, but not because of Syd herself. He tells her about seeing his sister while in the MRI machine. He can’t just leave his sister. Syd insists that David stay long enough to learn to learn what they can do together.
That way, after the work, they can rescue her. Plus, Syd knows that Amy won’t be killed by Division Three because she’s bait. David relents. He’ll stick around.
The episode ends with The Eye bringing a fish tank of leeches with him into the dingy room where Amy is being held. It’s time to begin.
We’re now at episode two of Legion and it’s not as off-the-wall as the pilot, but that’s just fine. The effects are just as outstanding as before, but this one slows down a bit in order to take us on a voyage through David’s mind.
As Dr. Bird says, he has to move past the message that’s been parroted to him for years. He’s not just some schizophrenic, but has special abilities that could prove beneficial both to himself and Dr. Bird’s team group at Summerland. Things are changing as he learns not just about his powers, but whether he can accept what is real and what’s just in his memory.
At least he has a great support network. We don’t know all of Melanie Bird’s motivations, but I like how she’s helping David understand his powers and how he can tap into them, as well as see them more as a gift instead of curse. It’s no accident that her mentoring is very similar to that of Charles Xavier aiding mutants come to terms with their powers.
But is that all? She just helps mutants learn to harness their abilities? Because as Ptonomy mentioned, Bird believes that David is the key to winning the war and other things. What other things? If we’re talking about a war with humans who capture and experiment on them, then that makes sense. But to what end? And what other things does Ptonomy mean?
I doubt we’re talking about an all out war against humanity for experimenting on humans, though it would not be unwarranted. It’s like Dr. Bird has all the teachings of Professor X, but maybe shares Magneto’s desire to battle against humans. That could be a stretch since there’s no reason yet to think Bird believes in mutant supremacy, but I am curious to see the depths of her plans for David.
As is, I liked both her and Ptonomy going into David’s mind to see what triggered his mutant abilities. I like how fractured some of these trips felt. Between the direction and writing, it feels like whenever the scene glitches or cuts in and out, it’s he’s still battling with his mind or that he can only remember things in fragments and pieces.
David feels like he’s always on the edge. He can sort of keep things under control, but either when pressed or taken to a certain point in his life, he loses it, as seen when he watches his father read a bedtime story to his younger self. This is as much a journey for him as it is for us as he still processes his true capabilities as a mutant.
I like the slow, methodical approach the show is taking to filling out David’s backstory and not spelling it all out at once. We see his drug escapades with Lenny before they were institutionalized, Dr. Poole discussing David’s condition, and David’s relationship troubles with his girlfriend, but these are just as important in telling us more about him as they are in revealing moments that led to his abilities manifesting. Memory work is brutal.
By the way, the combination of Ptonomy’s abilities and the group grabbing the rods while at the table felt very reminiscent of Cerebro. And Ptonomy, from what I got here, is a very laid back mutant who has been through this many times.
Being able to remember every single thing from your life, even before your birth, though, is a scary thought, coupled with examining moments where a person’s powers manifest. Sounds like a stressful job, but he handles it with care and it’s nice that he, like Syd and Bird, isn’t trying to force David. After all, as he said, he’s just the memory guy. He can only help unlock one piece of the larger puzzle.
For now, even though David is as conflicted as ever, he stays because Syd assures him that the training will help him unlock his true potential. Not to mention it allows the two to bond more. Their relationship is an odd one- well, they are an odd couple- but there’s such strong chemistry between Dan Stevens and Rachel Keller that I soak up any screen time they have together. I loved that “romance of the mind” line.
In addition, there’s still much more to learn about Syd and her abilities. We learn that she was in a similar position to David when she arrived, but don’t know the full scope of her powers. She has an intimate connection with David due to being in his body and accidentally killing Lenny when she lost control, but David accepts her nonetheless.
And she’s even willing to go as far as holding hands, against her rule, if it meant David would stay. Sure, some of that is out of concern for him not putting in the work yet, but part of that also has to be from how she cares about him.
But at the moment, David doesn’t have a choice but to stay if he wants to improve so he can safe Amy without fail. I do wonder what plans The Eye- and I’m guessing Division Three as a whole- have for her. The fact that she went looking for David should prove she doesn’t know where he is, but that doesn’t mean she can’t be coerced or tortured.
And on an unrelated note, we learn more about David’s father and his interest in astronomy. I hope we see more of him later on, not just to learn about David’s upbringing, but to see if Legion will play with David’s connection to Charles Xavier.
Chapter 2 peels back the layers of David Haller’s mind as he tries to understand his abilities, what triggered them, and how he’ll be useful to Melanie Bird. We see more of David’s powers and vulnerabilities, but with time, he’ll hopefully gain more control of his powers.
At the same time, we see his continued struggles, glimpses of the Devil with Yellow Eyes that continues to torment his mind, and on top of that, Amy is in the hands of The Eye. David better start training hard.